Lay Witnesses Save the Day--At Trial

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Melissa Miller

By Melissa Miller, Associate

The recent liability trial of DaSilva v. Dona et al, demonstrated the ultimate credibility contest – a classic “she-said/she-said.” The Jury was charged with the sole issue of deciding the truth about who was driving the car in a single vehicle accident.

Our client initially said that she was in the driver’s seat the night of the accident, in order to protect her friend, the defendant, from getting into trouble for driving without a license. She was also scared at the time. This lie was a difficult hurdle to overcome, but ultimately, the jury decided in our client’s favour – that it was, in fact, the defendant who was driving the car that night.

In this case, the “lay witnesses” made all the difference. Lay witnesses typically have no interest in the outcome of the lawsuit and they are generally impartial. This makes them more believable. As well, having a lay witness give evidence can often be more convincing than expert opinion evidence, as their testimony is not only easier to understand than an expert’s explanation of the same issue, but that person can speak to daily observations versus a one-time assessment.

One of the witnesses in DaSilva v. Dona et al, was an eye witness who had sustained a brain injury and therefore had no recollection of the accident itself. We had a difficult time locating him, but our efforts paid off, when he remembered that the defendant had been driving just prior to the accident occurring. The other crucial witness, who was also difficult to find, was the defendant’s ex-boyfriend. These lay witnesses were not without their own credibility problems, but their evidence was necessary for the win, as both witnesses supplemented the credibility of our client.

It is imperative in any lawsuit that lay witnesses be located and interviewed thoroughly, well before trial. The lay witnesses in DaSilva v. Dona highlight the importance of obtaining lay witnesses at an early stage in the proceeding. Statements from lay witnesses can be very persuasive for settlement purposes, not just at trial.

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Melissa MillerFor more information on this case or about witnesses or trials and how Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP can help you, please contact Melissa Miller 416-847-1063 or mmiller@hshlawyers.com.


Recent Blog Posts

Recent News

Upcoming Events

Among the best in Canada

Since 2011, our peers have consistently voted for us as one of Canada’s top personal injury firms in Canadian Lawyer magazine’s annual rankings of the top personal injury boutiques in Canada.

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Canadian Lawyer Magazine 2022

Tell us what happened

Our team of highly-trained lawyers are here to listen and help.

chevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram