The Importance of Knowing the Law Governing Offers

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Meghan M. Hull Jacquin

Though the decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal in Rider v Dydyk has been around for over 5 years, it seems that Rule 49 Offers are often unclear and the subject of debate. Often Insurers make their Rule 49 Offer on a net basis for general damages (which, if below $100,000.00 is subject to a $30,000.00 deductible for the main plaintiff and a $15,000.00 deductible for any plaintiffs under the Family Law Act). In order to trigger Rule 49 cost consequences, the Offer must include the gross amount of general damages.

The Court of Appeal in Rider v Dydyk, 2007 On C.A. 687, held that offers of settlement that fairly reflect the plaintiff's actual damages, without deduction, will encourage settlement. The Court of Appeal found that the Divisional Court's 2004 decision in Wicken v Harssar was wrong in its interpretation of the interaction between ss. 267.5(7) and 267.5(9) of the Insurance Act and Rule 49 of the Rules of Civil Procedure. It confirmed that "the correct interpretation is in accordance with the clear words used - the statutory deductions from a plaintiff's assessed damages are not to be considered in determining a party's entitlement to costs". In this case, the amount of the award to the Plaintiffs before the statutory deductible was greater than the Defendant's Rule 49 Offer, so the Defendant was not entitled to costs from the date of its Offer.

It is important that both Defendants and Plaintiffs know the law governing Offers when crafting and considering Offers as they could have considerable cost consequences.

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Meghan M. Hull JacquinFor more information on Offers contact Meghan M. Hull Jacquin (416) 361-7561 or mhull@hshlawyers.com.


Recent Blog Posts

Recent News

Upcoming Events

Among the best in Canada

Since 2011, our peers have consistently voted for us as one of Canada’s top personal injury firms in Canadian Lawyer magazine’s annual rankings of the top personal injury boutiques in Canada.

Howie, Sacks & Henry LLP – Personal Injury Law – Canadian Lawyer Magazine 2022

Tell us what happened

Our team of highly-trained lawyers are here to listen and help.

chevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram